The Good Nursery is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

7 Best Organic Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad Options for Babies

8 Best Organic Waterproof Mattress Pad Options for Babies

Are you looking for the best organic mattress protectors that can provide maximum comfort for your child?

Worry no more because this article will help you!

An organic waterproof mattress protector is one of the best sustainable products you can buy for your home, as it is made with conventional cotton filling, organic wool, and natural fibers.

Your baby AND entire family will benefit from this waterproof mattress protector because it has an enhanced sleeping surface, breathable protection, and DrySleep technology.

Scroll down to find the best organic waterproof crib mattress pad for your baby!

Best Overall
Best Value
Budget Option

SureGuard Crib Size Mattress Protector

COZYCUDDLES Quilted Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector

American Baby Company Fitted Crib Protective Mattress Pad Cover

Best Overall
SureGuard Crib Size Mattress Protector
Best Value
COZYCUDDLES Quilted Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector
Budget Option
American Baby Company Fitted Crib Protective Mattress Pad Cover
Table of Contents
Table of Contents

Top 7 Organic Waterproof Mattress Protectors and Pads

An infant’s skin and health are susceptible to irritants, dust particles, toxic chemicals; the list goes on!

With this, many mattress protectors provide the best protection against harsh chemicals and work best to maintain and secure your child’s health.

If you are looking for an organic mattress protector, listed below are my mattress protector suggestions!

1. SureGuard Crib Size Mattress Protector


SureGuard Crib Size Mattress Protector

Material: Organic cotton

One of the BEST organic cotton mattress protectors in town is the SureGuard mattress protector!

Most first-time parents choose this organic mattress because it is an enduring protector from flame retardants and water vapor.

It is made with organic certified cotton, the cotton terry surface, so your baby can sleep soundly while its waterproof feature prevents liquid from seeping into the mattress.

I recommend this organic mattress protector because its fabric is permeable and naturally absorbs moisture while dissipating heat for an excellent night’s sleep.

Also, this green mattress has a wide and full elastic perimeter for the fitted sheet and GOTS-certified organic cotton for baby use.

Say goodbye to bacteria, mildew, and mold thanks to its SureGuard hypoallergenic mattress protector!

Additionally, the SureGuard company provides a full refund if the mattress is damaged and a 10-year guarantee!

I can assure you that this is the best organic mattress protector on the market, as it aids in reducing sweat, has a breathable barrier, and is made with non-toxic chemicals!

It is also offered in different sizes such as twin, twin XL, full and full XL, California king, and crib.


  • Super soft
  • Made with organic materials
  • Easy to clean
  • GOTS-certified organic
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • Waterproof mattress protectors


  • It can be slightly noisy
  • May get a little warm

2. COZYCUDDLES Quilted Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector



Material: Microfiber, organic cotton

The COZYCUDDLES premium pad is a beautiful addition to any non-toxic crib for a baby!

It is made with organic materials to produce a good night’s sleep. Also, this GOTS-certified organic cotton is an organic waterproof that aids in preventing leaks.

This organic mattress has a zippered closure, so it will stay in place even if your fussy baby tosses and turns all night!

This is a good option for babies because it is made of soft, breathable, and completely hypoallergenic natural fabrics that do not irritate the skin.

From my experience, I can say that it is one of the best organic waterproof mattresses you can ever find! I almost wanted to sleep on it myself!

This cotton mattress protector also received a certification from the Consumer Product Safety Commission, which can keep out bed bugs and mites!


  • GOTS-certified
  • Made with soft organic materials
  • Comes in Twin XL and California King sizes
  • Similar to a Naturepedic mattress protector


  • It may produce low heat.

3. American Baby Company Fitted Crib Protective Mattress Pad Cover


American Baby Company Fitted Crib Protective Mattress Pad Cover

Material: Organic cotton, soft polyester

The American Baby Company Fitted Crib Mattress Pad Cover is one of the best organic mattress protectors you can ever find if you are on a tight budget!

Unlike other protectors, this mattress protector is made with top-quality organic cotton, deep pockets, and a snug fit.

I like this organic mattress protector because it provides a simple solution to stop mold and moisture from growing.

Also, this mattress protector has a soft polyester top and bottom and a waterproof middle layer that offers COMFORT and SECURITY.

This certified organic cotton protector allows your child to sleep comfortably thanks to its quilt-like pattern on the top of the cover, which adds softness without adding bulk.

Additionally, the mattress protector from the American Baby Company has an elastic edging and low setting that holds it in place to prevent any unwanted leaking.

This certified organic cotton mattress is designed to be machine washable for easy mattress clean-up.

This GOTS-certified organic cotton is available in twin XL, crib, and California king size.


  • Has liquid barrier
  • GOTS-certified
  • Made with non toxic and organic materials


  • Excessive harsh washing is likely to cause damage.

4. Plushbeds


Material: Natural wool

If there is one thing I love about Plush Bed products, it is there are NO harsh chemicals or dyes used in the construction of the mattress protector!

Plush Bed is GOTS-certified organic cotton as it is dedicated to producing ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY products.

This protector is packaged in biodegradable hemp and corn film.

I love this product because while this mattress offers a superior water barrier, it is also incredibly thin and almost invisible under the sheets!

Each cover is sized to fit a typical mattress profile up to 14″ deep and is available in various sizes.

Also, I love that it is offered in various bed sizes, from Twin XL to California King!

Additionally, you can purchase this mattress protector confidently because a 5-Year Limited Warranty backs it.


  • GOTS-certified
  • 5-year warranty
  • Available in all sizes


  • Expensive price

5. Swaddlez Mini Crib Waterproof Mattress Pad

Swaddlez Mini Crib Waterproof Mattress Pad

Material: Polyester, Bamboo Viscose

The best certified organic cotton for mini cribs is the Swaddlez Mini Crib Pad.

This GOTS-certified organic cotton comprises three layers: polyester filling, bamboo viscose, and a TPU water-resisting membrane.

These organic materials ensure that your baby has a comfortable night’s sleep as it is a natural cleaner and freshener!

What I love about these protectors is their comfortable technology which maintains the sleeping quality of your child!

Also, I adore how SOFT this pad is, and I love that it is offered in different sizes.


  • Made with non toxic organic materials
  • Enhance sleep quality
  • GOTS-certified organic cotton mattress


  • It might shrink when washed on a machine dryer.

6. Whisper Organics’ Cotton Mattress Pad Protector

Whisper Organics' Cotton Mattress Pad Protector

Material: 100% organic cotton

One of the market’s best organic cotton mattress protectors is the Organic Cotton Pad Protector from Whisper!

This protector is made with 100% cotton, which received a certification from Global Organic Textile Standard!

What I love about these models of organic mattress protectors is their extreme durability! I have been using this mattress for a long time, and it is still in good condition!

Also, I adore how these organic mattress protectors stay true to their nature because they are devoid of several harmful chemicals, including BPA, lead, phthalates, and latex.

If you are looking for organic cotton, I suggest trying GOTS-certified organic cotton.

I assure you your baby will have the best bed and sleep quality!


  • Vegan and chemical-free
  • Made of organic cotton
  • GOTS-certified organic
  • Easy to wash


  • Expensive price

7. Masirs Organic Mattress Protectors

Masirs Organic Mattress Protectors

Material: Bamboo

Masirs’ non toxic crib mattress protector is made to keep your child’s mattress safe all night while also keeping them comfortable while they sleep.

This hypoallergenic crib mattress protector from Masirs, known for its secure and all-natural baby products, is no exception!

 I’m glad my baby can sleep while feeling cool and comfortable all night, which most mattress protectors lack.

What I love about these organic mattress protectors is that they are made of SAFE, non toxic materials and intended to act as a waterproof barrier!

Also, these mattress protectors are breathable in addition to being water-resistant.

The all-natural bamboo used to make these organic mattress protectors are known for being soft, breathable, and comfortable.

Additionally, this all-natural material naturally repels mold and blocks mites, which is great for sensitive kids or who might have allergies.

When it comes to keeping your baby safe and comfortable, Masirs’ waterproof mattress protectors truly offer the best of both worlds!


  • Made with bamboo and certified organic cotton
  • Ultra-soft
  • Affordable price


  • Not dryer-proof
  • May stain easily

What to Look for in an Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector

Choosing mattress protectors is a lot of work because you must make sure you purchase the best product.

However, to help you choose a certified organic cotton mattress, listed below are the key factors!



When looking for mattress protectors, you must first consider the fabric and its water-resistant ability.

Vinyl, cotton, polyester, and occasionally bamboo blends are the most common materials used to make mattress protectors.

These materials provide MAXIMUM COMFORT and also help in preventing slippage as these are made with organic cotton.

Your choice of material will mostly depend on your personal preferences.



Your mattress protector can perform multiple protective functions, similar to mattress toppers.

You might require a waterproof protector to keep a child’s mattress dry during potty training and a hypoallergenic protector.

Also, you must require a bedbug-resistant protector that completely encases your mattress rather than just covering the top.

Some protectors can fulfill those requirements, while others concentrate more on a single duty.

Mattress Fit

Mattress Fit

When choosing a protector, ensure it will fit your organic crib mattress snugly.

A loose fit can make the protector noisier when you move at night and offers more opportunities for bugs, mites, and liquid to seep through your mattress.

Not to mention, a loose fit can also lead to a cranky baby! Trust me, I know.



Of course, since your baby will be sleeping on this mattress pad, you want to ensure its safety. That’s why it’s important to look for mattress pads made from safe, organic materials.

Some of the best materials to look for are organic cotton, wool, and natural latex.

Not only are these materials baby-safe, but they will enhance your baby’s sleep, thanks to their comfort and gentleness.



One way to guarantee the safety and organic integrity of a mattress pad is to look for official certifications.

You will find seals labeled GOTS-certified or Oeko-Tex, which indicate that the product has undergone rigorous testing for harmful chemicals and PASSED standard safety guidelines.

EXTRA TIP: If you need help choosing a mattress for your baby’s crib, Naturepedic has several safe options. Check out this buying guide of the best Naturepedic mattresses to get started!

What to AVOID in an Organic Mattress Protector

If you are new to buying mattress protectors, you should AVOID these materials:



If your waterproof mattress protectors have formaldehyde, you will likely experience constant irritation on the nose, throat, and skin.

Also, it can lead to an increased risk of coughing and wheezing.

Polybrominated Diphenyl Ethers

Polybrominated Diphenyl Ethers

Mattresses with polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) are linked to reduced fertility and hormonal changes.

With this, you must be cautious in choosing mattresses because one mistake could lead to another.



Toluene is what makes your waterproof mattress protectors soft and flexible.

However, it is linked to causing human carcinogens, according to a report from the National Institutes of Health.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

I know that buying a protector may raise many questions, but don’t worry! Listed below are the possible questions you might ask and their answers.

What Is the Best Material for a Mattress Cover?

Pick a mattress protector that is made ENTIRELY of cotton.

Cotton is absorbent and soft and has a more natural structure than synthetic fibers, which allows it to breathe better.

Do You Put Sheets Over an Organic Mattress Protector?

Yes, you MUST cover your mattress protector with sheets! Your back and spine will be subject to pain if you lie in bed without a protector.

How Often Should You Wash the Mattress Protector?

A mattress protector should be washed every two months, according to recommendations.

However, if spills happen or if you let pets sleep on the bed, you might need to wash them more frequently.

Can the Mattress Pad Be Used With Any Type of Crib Mattress?

Most mattress pads are designed to fit standard-sized crib mattresses, so it shouldn’t be too much of a problem.

However, if you aren’t sure, double-check the measurements of your crib mattress and the mattress pad to ensure it fits.

What Are the Benefits of Using an Organic Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad?

Organic, waterproof mattress pads have several benefits, including less exposure to harmful chemicals, and they are gentler on the baby’s skin.

They also contribute to safer and sounder sleep.

If your baby makes messes often, you don’t have to worry about cleaning up as it protects the mattress from stains and makes cleaning up easier.

Can the Mattress Pad Be Used as a Standalone Mattress for My Baby?


Mattress pads aren’t as thick or comfortable as a regular mattress, so your baby’s sleep will not be comfortable either.

How Do I Know if a Mattress Pad is Truly Organic and Non-Toxic?

The best way to ensure that a mattress pad is safe is to look for certifications.

Seals like GOTS-certified and Oeko-Tex are official declarations that products are free of toxic chemicals and made with organic materials.

How Do I Maintain the Waterproofing of the Mattress Pad?

For starters, avoid using bleach and other harsh chemicals when cleaning them, as they may destroy the waterproof layer.

Avoid using high heat and tumble-dry the pad on low heat.

My Favorite Picks

My Favorite Picks

And now we are on my favorite part! Let us look at my favorite picks among all the protectors.

Budget Option – American Baby Company Fitted Crib Protective Mattress Pad Cover

The American Baby is the best mattress that protects your child if you are on a tight budget!

It is the best and simple solution to stop mold and moisture from growing because it is made from high-quality materials!

I recommend these mattresses because they are machine washable, which makes them extremely easy to clean!

Best Value – CozyCuddles

If you are concerned that your child might encounter dust mites and bed bugs, the Cozycuddles are the mattresses you need!

It received a Consumer Product Safety Commission certification because it can keep out bed bugs and dust mites.

Also, these products are made with organic materials, which ENHANCES your child’s sleep quality!

I love these mattresses because it is made of soft, breathable, and completely hypoallergenic natural fabrics that do not irritate the skin.

Best Overall – SureGuard Crib Size Mattress Protector

Simple but effective!

This water-resistant mattress is made with organic cotton, which enhances your child’s sleep because it has soft fabrics.

I love this product because it aids in preventing the build-up of bacteria, mold, and mildew.

Also, it has a breathable barrier and is made with non-toxic and child-friendly chemicals.


Choosing a protector might be hard for some because it requires a thorough evaluation and selection.

If you need my advice, look for protectors that are made of organic materials that prevent slippage and are easy to wash!

Also, look for a protector that can cover two layers of mattresses and a protector with two-inch quilted squares for more comfortable and sound sleep quality!

However, the best protector you can ever find is the one that fits your preference!

FINAL TIP: For your kid to have the best sleep, you can try any of these organic toddler pillows to make them feel more comfy!

About the author

Angelica Graham

A few years ago, Angelica found out about all the plastic and toxic ingredients that got into most children’s products. And this worried her to no end. Because of this, she began to research what the best ingredients and materials were for children and made it her mission to share this information with other mothers.