7 Best Naturepedic Crib Mattresses for Your Baby and Budget

When it comes to crib mattresses, Naturepedic is well known for the quality, trustworthiness, and safety of their products.

They sell a bunch of the best crib mattresses for the safe sleep of any baby!

In this list, we broke down the three different types of crib mattresses Naturepedic has to offer. Each type comes with a few variants with different core supports.

Check out the best Naturepedic crib mattress options and see which one will work best for you and your baby!

7 Best Naturepedic Crib Mattress Options

1. Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress

Out of the seven Naturpedic organic crib mattress variants you can choose from, our TOP PICK is the Breathable 2-Stage Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress.

The Breathable line is their midrange line that isn’t as affordable as the Classic line. It also isn’t as expensive as the Breathable Ultra line. This hits the sweet spot for most parents!

This organic crib mattress is breathable, lightweight, waterproof, and dual-sided. It has a firm side, which is perfect for infants, while the other side is a bit softer, which is comfier for toddlers.

Their Breathable mattresses come with a removable organic cotton fabric cover that’s machine washable.

This cover isn’t waterproof, so if ever your baby has diaper blowouts or spills, you can just remove the cover. The mattress still works great without it!

The surface of the mattress is made of certified organic cotton and applied with a safe food-grade plastic coating. This is a SAFE waterproofing method, so this isn’t something you should worry about!

A waterproof organic crib mattress is best because you don’t have to worry about mold, mildew, and dust mites from getting inside the mattress. These mattresses are the easiest to maintain for a long time!

The filling of Naturepedic crib mattresses is made with organic cotton mixed with non-GMO PLA batting.

Their PLA batting is made from sugarcane, helping their mattresses meet flammability standards without using flame retardants!

The “Lightweight” part of Naturepedic organic crib mattresses refers to their trademarked Wavesupport core. Instead of using traditional innerspring coils, they use this core technology.

It’s half as light compared to coils while still being sturdy enough for good support!

All Naturepedic mattresses are free of fire-retardant chemicals, chemical emissions, PVC, and other harmful substances. They have different safety certifications to show for it too!

They also offer a limited lifetime warranty, so that’s great!

2. Naturepedic Classic Lightweight 2-Stage Baby Crib Mattress

If you’re looking to get the best bargain for your little one’s crib mattress, then the Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight 2-Stage variant is your BEST BET!

Like all other Naturepedic mattresses, it’s made of certified organic cotton inside and out. It also has PLA batting and has a waterproof coating.

The Organic Cotton Classic line doesn’t come with any mattress cover; it’s just a bare mattress with a wipe-clean surface for easy cleaning and maintenance.

It’s also FREE of harmful substances like flame retardant chemicals, formaldehyde, lead, PVC, and other toxic chemicals.

This is also a dual firmness mattress, which is what gives it great value. One side is firm for infants, while the other is softer for older babies.

Without the additional breathable mattress pad cover, it becomes lighter and more affordable!

This organic crib mattress is only a pound heavier than the lightest crib mattress on this list. Although, the added benefit of dual firmness makes it a long-lasting solution that won’t break the bank!

Since it’s “Lightweight”, this mattress uses the Wavesupport core of Naturepedic.

3. Naturepedic Breathable Ultra Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress

The Breathable Ultra line is a step above the standard Breathable mattress line. This variant shares the same features as the Breathable 2-Stage Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress.

The only difference is the organic cotton cover.

This mattress type has an organic cotton fabric cover with a special quilted design, making it feel more luxurious and comfortable for your baby, while still being breathable!

This is also a dual firmness mattress that works great for both infants and toddlers. Since it’s also “Lightweight,” it has the Wavesupport core as well.

This product belongs to the high-end line of Naturepedic crib mattress types!

If you’re willing to spend a bit more for the extra comfort and breathability of your baby, this crib mattress is the one for you!

You also don’t need to worry about flame retardant chemicals and other toxic substances in this mattress line.

4. Naturepedic Classic Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress

Lightweight & Affordable Option

If you want to try out a Naturepedic organic crib mattress for your newborn, this baby’s crib mattress is a great entry-level pick that fits the bill.

Weighing at 10 lbs, this is one of the lightest organic crib mattresses you can find on the market!

Since it’s still a Naturepedic mattress, it isn’t a budget option. Although, it’s the most affordable Naturepedic crib mattress you can get your hands on!

It’s more affordable because it’s only a single-firmness mattress.

Whichever sleep surface side you choose, it will have the same firm feeling. This mattress is only meant for the safe sleep of infants. Older babies might not feel comfortable with this crib mattress.

It has the same Wavesupport core, making other Lightweight variants easy to carry. It still gives all the support your infant will need for safe sleep.

Besides the single-firmness feature, this crib mattress shares the same features as the Organic Cotton Classic 2-Stage Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress.

5. Naturepedic Classic Innerspring 150 Baby Crib Mattress

Value Innerspring Option

Moving away from the Lightweight Wavesupport core variants, we have the Innerspring mattress variants.

Traditional mattresses use innerspring coils for inside support.

These are made of steel, which is durable and naturally fire-resistant. No flame retardant chemicals are used for these coils, so that’s great!

The number of coils can differ depending on how effective they want the weight distribution to be. The higher the coil count, the better the weight distribution.

Stability and weight distribution are important for the safe sleep of infants!

There are times when your baby can end up sleeping on the edges of the mattress. As much as possible, you don’t want these sides to dip down and create any gaps.

This can be a hazard for your baby!

Naturepedic mattresses effectively use their Wavesupport and Innerspring cores to prevent this from happening.

For their Organic Cotton Classic line, they have an Innerspring 150 coil variant.

This is a dual-firmness mattress that’s suitable for infants and toddlers. Other than the difference in the core support, this product shares the same features as its Wavesupport counterpart.

Since this uses innerspring coils, it’s a couple of pounds heavier, and it’s not as easy to carry and maneuver.

6. Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage Innerspring 252 Baby Crib Mattress

Breathable Innerspring Option

If you’re interested in the Breathable option but want an innerspring core, this is the one for you.

This innerspring crib mattress shares the same features as its Wavesupport counterpart. It’s only a bit heavier because of the 252 coils, but it is more stable and reliable for long use.

Expect the same organic cotton cover and other features that make the Breathable line a great midrange option!

7. Naturepedic Breathable Ultra Innerspring 252 Baby Crib Mattress

Luxury Innerspring Option

Just like the other Innerspring variants, this one shares the same features as its Wavesupport counterpart.

It has a breathable quilted cotton cover, it’s two-sided, and it’s made of safe materials that are free of harmful chemicals. The only difference is the 252 coil core support instead of the Wavesupport core.

This product is at the TOP of the list regarding the price of their organic crib mattress options. If you’re looking for the most high-end Naturepedic crib mattress, this product takes the cake!

About Naturepedic

Naturepedic is a family-owned mattress company that started back in 2003.

Back then, the founder of the company, who has been an environmental engineer for over 30 years, was looking for a safe, non-toxic, and organic crib mattress for his first grandchild.

Sadly, he couldn’t find any suitable mattress that would fit his safety criteria. In trying to come up with a solution, he found the mattress company Naturepedic.

This company has been providing some of the best organic crib mattresses in the market today!

Not only do they sell organic mattresses for little ones, but they make organic adult mattresses too. All of their mattresses have safety certifications from different review boards.

You won’t find any PVC, polyurethane foam, flame retardants, and other toxic substances in any of their mattresses. This company is a certified safe mattress brand you can trust!

The 3 Types of Naturepedic Crib Mattresses

For their organic crib mattresses, they have three main types. The Classic Mattress, Breathable Mattress, and Breathable Ultra Mattress.

They use the same safe materials for these three mattress types. Although, there are a couple of differences that sets each one apart.

Classic

Their Classic crib mattress is the lightest and most affordable of the three types. This doesn’t come with a removable cover, so it’s just a seamless, wipe-clean waterproof surface.

The Classic has three different variants you can choose from. The Lightweight, Lightweight 2-Stage, and Innerspring 150.

The Lightweight variant is the lightest and most affordable of all their organic crib mattresses mainly because of their trademarked Wavesupport core. It’s lighter than coil innerspring mattresses by a few pounds.

Thanks to that special core, this crib mattress only weighs 10 lbs! It’s also a single firmness or single-sided mattress, firm on both sides and meant for infants only.

If you’re looking for a lightweight mattress that would also work great for older babies, the Lightweight 2-Stage is the one for you.

It’s basically the same as the Lightweight variant, but it has one side that feels softer and comfier for toddlers.

For the last variant, the Innerspring 150 option uses 150 innerspring coils as the core. This makes it a bit heavier, but it also provides great STABILITY and gives the standard feel of mattresses you might be accustomed to.

It’s also a double-sided crib mattress, so this mattress can last a long time since toddlers can also use it comfortably.

Breathable

The Breathable mattress line is an upgrade to the Classic line that comes with an additional breathable organic cotton cover. This cotton cover isn’t waterproof but is removable and machine washable.

The breathable pad is great for maximizing airflow in and out of the mattress. This can prevent sweaty backs and uncomfortable situations for your baby!

What’s great is that you can still use this crib mattress even WITHOUT the breathable cotton cover!

If there are accidents during the night, you can just remove the cover, clean the waterproof surface, and gently place your baby back on the mattress.

You can also just get additional breathable covers if you want. Having these in stock for easy replacements is convenient! It also ensures that the breathable function lasts throughout the rest of the night.

The Breathable line has two variants you can choose from that are both double-sided and work great for both infants and toddlers.

The first variant has the lightweight Wavesupport core, while the second variant has an innerspring 252 coil core.

Breathable Ultra

A step above the Breathable line is the Breathable Ultra. The only difference this has is the organic cotton cover.

Instead of a standard cover design, this one has a quilted design.

This feels softer, comfier, and more luxurious for your baby while still feeling firm and breathable! It’s also more durable, so that’s great!

The Breathable Ultra mattress line has two variants as well. One is the lightweight Wavesupport core, and the other is the innerspring 252 coil core.

You can also stock up on additional quilted covers in case of accidents.

Single-Sided vs. Double-Sided

When it comes to organic crib mattresses, you can either get a single-sided/single firmness mattress or a double-sided/dual firmness mattress.

A single-sided mattress has the same sleep surface on both sides. It feels firm and it’s designed for the safe sleep of infants.

Double-sided mattresses have two different sides. One side is firm and meant for infants, while the other side is softer and comfier. This side is meant for toddlers and older kids.

A dual-firmness crib mattress is your best bet in terms of value and longevity.

Even after your infant turns a year old, you can continue using the same mattress on the same crib. Just flip the mattress over, and you have a toddler mattress that can last you for a couple more years!

For Naturepedic crib mattresses, only the Classic Lightweight variant is single-sided. All other variants and crib mattress lines are double-sided mattresses that work great for both infants and toddlers.

Lightweight Wavesupport Core vs. Innerspring Core

For the three crib mattress lines that Naturepedic has, they offer two core supports you can choose from. The Lightweight Wavesupport core and the Innerspring Core.

Both cores are made of safe materials you don’t have to worry about! They also give proper stability and edge support, which is important for the safe sleep of infants.

The edge support ensures a safer sleep for your little one. When your baby sleeps on the edges of the mattress, it won’t compress down and make any gaps.

The edges will stay firm and keep your baby safe as if they were sleeping in the center!

The Wavesupport core is made of non-toxic, food-grade plastic. It’s also LIGHTER than traditional innerspring coils by up to half!

This is a great alternative that’s cheaper, lighter, and makes it easier for any mom to carry and handle the mattress.

The innerspring coils are made of steel and provide better durability and stability. The number of coils also determines how effective the weight distribution would be.

The Classic Lightweight Innerspring 150 only has 150 coils, but it provides all the coils you’ll need for infants.

The rest of the innerspring variants have 252 coils. These work best for toddlers and give them all the support they’ll need for a good night’s sleep!

You can’t go wrong with either core support!

Although, if you’re looking for a lighter mattress that’s easier to handle, the Wavesupport core will not disappoint. It’s more affordable too, so that’s a plus!

Materials Used on Naturepedic Crib Mattresses

Naturepedic is a transparent company that provides all the information parents are looking for when it comes to the materials of all their crib mattress options.

They don’t just greenwash their products and market them as “safer” and “eco-friendly” to entice customers.

They’re a genuine company that uses certified-safe materials that are responsibly sourced. You even check out their annual sustainability report on their website!

Their organic crib mattresses are mostly made up of safe, natural materials, and any non-organic materials are non-toxic and safe for any baby!

Organic Cotton

Naturepedic crib mattresses are mostly made of certified organic cotton. This includes the mattress surface, the filling on the inside, and the breathable covers.

Organic cotton is a lot SAFER compared to standard cotton!

Certified organic cotton is FREE of harmful chemicals, safe for your baby, and friendlier to the environment!

Meanwhile, standard cotton usually has tons of pesticides and is processed with different chemicals. How it’s obtained and processed is also ethically questionable for the environment’s safety.

All of their organic cotton fabrics are certified in the US and purchased directly from USDA-certified sources.

PLA Batting

To pass flammability safety tests, Naturepedic uses verified-safe PLA batting, which is made from non-GMO sugarcane. This material is mixed in with the organic cotton surface and filling.

Instead of bursting into flames when exposed to fire, this material only smolders. This characteristic is enough to pass federal flammability tests without using any flame-retardant chemicals!

Food-Grade Polyethylene

A waterproof crib mattress is more important than you think!

Leaks and accidents can happen, so having a waterproof crib mattress can make things easier to clean for any parent.

It helps make mattress maintenance easier too!

Additionally, a waterproof organic crib mattress means that no liquids can go through the surface and into the mattress.

You don’t have to worry about molds, mildew, and dust mites ruining it!

To achieve this, Naturepedic uses food-grade polyethylene coating mixed with organic cotton.

This material is also derived from non-GMO sugarcane, and it’s a safe plastic that’s also used for food containers! The Wavesupport core is also made of this safe material.

Despite their mattresses not being 100% organic, they’re still innovatively designed to be safe, non-toxic, and beneficial for parents and babies!

Certifications of Naturepedic Crib Mattresses

Another reason why Naturepedic is recognized as a safe and reliable mattress brand is its safety certifications.

These certifications aren’t just for show, they ensure that their products are made of truly safe and organic and have no toxic chemicals!

Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)

The Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) is one of the BEST certifications for the trustworthiness and safety of materials.

They follow strict toxicity criteria when reviewing organic materials.

They should meet all environmental, social, and human safety standards! For a product to be GOTS certified, it has to be made of at least 95% certified organic fibers.

All GOTS-certified products are also free of harmful substances like formaldehyde and heavy metals.

On top of certifying that materials are organic and safe, they also look out for the workers involved in acquiring these materials.

Manufacturers shouldn’t be involved in forced labor, or excessive working hours, and they should be working in safe and non-hazardous conditions!

All Naturepedic crib mattresses are made of GOTS-certified organic cotton, while other mattresses also use GOTS-certified organic wool.

MADE SAFE

A MADE-SAFE certified product is FREE of any ingredients that are known or suspected to cause any harm to humans, animals, and ecosystems.

They check for polyurethane foam, toxins, carcinogens, flame retardants, heavy metals, pesticides, solvents, VOCs, and other harmful substances!

Experts and scientists strictly review Naturepedic crib mattresses to be free of harmful chemicals and ensure that only safe materials are used!

GREENGUARD Gold

A GREENGUARD Gold certification is another important safety certification, but it focuses on volatile organic compounds (VOCs).

If a mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified, it means that it’s reviewed and tested to emit low levels of VOC emissions.

Formaldehyde is a common VOC that’s present in standard glue and manufactured wood. Naturepedic doesn’t use glue on any of their mattresses, so that should ease your mind.

Beware of polyurethane foam as well!

Polyurethane foam also contains VOCs, and these usually off-gas into the atmosphere that your baby can inhale. Thankfully, Naturepedic doesn’t use polyurethane foam on any of its crib mattresses!

On top of a crib mattress that has a GREENGUARD Gold certification, you should also pair it with a solid wood non-toxic crib that’s also certified.

Solid wood has low levels of VOCs and formaldehyde compared to composite/manufactured wood!

Conclusion

The Naturepedic Breathable 2-Stage Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress is our top recommendation for Naturepedic mattresses.

It checks all boxes for being a great organic mattress, and it shares qualities that make the other foam mattress types great. This is a great mid-range product that will work great for a lot of parents!

For those who already have fitted crib sheets or want to spend a little less on an organic crib mattress, the Naturepedic Classic Lightweight 2-Stage Baby Crib Mattress is an easy pick.

It works for infants and toddlers, it’s lightweight, and it doesn’t cost as much as higher-end Naturepedic mattresses.

If you’re looking to get the best comfort for your baby and have a big budget, the Naturepedic Breathable Ultra 2-Stage Lightweight Baby Crib Mattress will not disappoint.

The quilted sheet will feel great for both babies and toddlers, and the breathable features will keep them cool throughout the night!

SAFETY REMINDER: Whatever mattress you choose, make sure that your baby does NOT sleep face down on the mattress! It will cause choking, breathing problems, and even SIDS!