The Good Nursery is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

10 Best Natural Teething Toys for Babies: Organic, Rubber

Natural Teething Toys

Before toothy smiles, it’s sore gums and drools everywhere.

Teething babies are trouble sometimes.

You’d want your baby to be a great biter like Sunny Baudelaire from The Series of Unfortunate Events the time they’re her age, right?

This article has our favorite natural teethers for your little one.

Table of Contents
Table of Contents

10 of the Best Organic & Natural Teething Toys for Babies

1. Itzy Ritzy Teething Mitt

Itzy Ritzy Teething Mitt

A little mitt for your baby’s little hands.

The Itzy Ritzy Teething Mitt is non-toxic, chemical-free, and made from food-grade silicone free of BPA and PVC. Not to mention it’s ABSOLUTELY ADORABLE.

Here’s a YouTube vid of the toy in preview:

Teething mitts are perfect for babies who have trouble gripping teething toys.

Not only do these soothe your baby’s gums from teething pain, but they also protect their faces from getting scratches and booboos.

It comes in different designs for the cutest little mitt that your baby could rock.

This is one of the best teething toys we can recommend!

2. Moonjax Baby Teether

Moonjax Baby Teether

The Moonjax Baby Teether is non-toxic, odorless, and COMPLETELY SAFE for your baby’s tender gums.

It’s made from 100% food-grade silicone, made clear for your baby without the use of harmful dyes and toxins.

One of the best things about these plastic-free, non-toxic teething toys is it’s also BPA-free, which PREVENTS toxic teething for your baby.

Teething toys are better the more versatile they come.

Teethers like this can be heated or frozen, which works wonders for pain relief for both the sore gums of your baby and the worrying hearts of moms.

3. Mini Tudou Soft Baby Building Blocks

Mini Tudou Soft Baby Building Blocks

For moms and caregivers who love to mix learning and play for their kids, the colorful Mini Tudou Blocks teether set is for your babies.

Another BPA-free pick of ours, this food-grade silicone teething toy will help soothe your baby’s gums with its soft, nontoxic bristles.

It’s stackable with designs you can learn from and multiple textures that help with baby teething. They even squeak when they’re squeezed!

Better have non-toxic teething toys around since a baby will always try to bite all kinds of things! Food-grade toys like this are PERFECT for babies from the age of 5 months and up.

Your baby would love not just a single piece, but a set of toys for their teething tendencies.

This is one of the best teething toys that’s actually more of a toy than a teether for your baby’s gums!

4. Calmies All-Natural Rubber Teething Toys

Calmies All-Natural Rubber Teething Toys

It’s either go green or go home for this Calmies rubber ball toy. Best to take it home to your little one instead.

Developed by a mom herself, this BPA teething toy is made from all-natural rubber, which prevents your baby from going through toxic teething.

This teether is made from the Hevea rubber tree. THAT MEANS it’s safe to go into your baby’s mouth, and it’s also safe for the planet. Non-toxic and eco-friendly right there!

Highly sustainable and natural teething toys. What else could your baby want, right?

5. Calmies RubbeeBlocks Teething Toy

Calmies RubbeeBlocks Teething Toy

Bet you thought you’d seen the last from this brand, huh?

Not AT ALL! Baby, come back to this.

Our personal favorite, as we decided to add this more-than-a-toy-than-it-is-a-teether into the post of non-toxic teething toys for your baby.

This is the Calmies RubbeeBlocks.

Truly a lovely sight when a mom shares her innovations for the love and care of our kids.

Made from the same Malaysian company as the number above this, they make teething toys eco-friendly for your baby to enjoy.

Used as an alternative to wood blocks, this is also made out of all-natural rubber. It’s free of BPA, and it will free your baby’s mouth and teeth of any discomfort when they play.

6. RaZbaby RaZ-Berry Silicone Teethers

RaZbaby RaZ-Berry Silicone Teethers

It’s another one of these BPA-free, food-grade silicone toys, but only this is shaped like a pacifier. Plus, it’s really cute and comes in adorable colors for your baby.

While some pacifiers are simple and don’t do much for teething pain relief, these RaZbaby RaZ-Berry Silicone Teethers certainly do.

The way that it can be frozen but not harden is just right for dealing with the sore gums of your baby.

It’s non-toxic and perfect for teething babies because of its shape. Made to be grasped by their tiny hands with ease, and stay in their mouths like pacifiers.

What baby wouldn’t be totally adorable with a raspberry-looking binky?

7. Lifefactory Multi-Sensory Latex and BPA-Free Silicone Teething Ring

Lifefactory Multi-Sensory Latex and BPA-Free Silicone Teething Ring

There’s something about the way babies grab items that are closest to them and just begin teething. It’s that stage of infancy with signs like that that let us know it’s time to get them teething toys.

You know by now that this post would include non-toxic teething toys made of food-grade silicone.

The Lifefactory Silicone Teething Ring is good for relieving the baby’s teething pain of sore gums since you can refrigerate it, but that’s not the coolest thing about it. Pun intended.

While some teething toys are just teething toys, this has 4 different sections to develop oral motor skills. It’s multi-sensory and was designed by a pediatric feeding specialist.

Non-toxic content is the best content, only for our precious babies.

8. Grimm’s Natural Wood European Baby Teether Grasping Toys

Grimm's Natural Wood European Baby Teether Grasping Toys

Grimm’s natural wood, non-toxic teething toys come in different shapes for creative-to-be babies.

Wood teethers such as these help babies with teeth more than teething babies. Some items such as these are created to combine play and skill.

In the picture is a lovely star with 10 colorful beads around it, but the company behind it makes them in all different shapes!

Aside from cutesy shapes and developing motor skills, these non-toxic teething toys also help your baby discover new textures for baby teething.

We know a mom or two that values learning for their babies, especially early on!

The German company behind these teethers makes all kinds of wooden teether toys!

9. Loulou Lollipop Taco Teether

Loulou Lollipop Taco Teether

Foodies would adore toys like this. Their teething baby would definitely enjoy this taco-looking Loulou Lollipop teether for teething as well.

These baby products are made with 100% food-grade silicone, are non-toxic for your baby, and are safe for their soft gums.

It’s free of BPA, free of any pain for soothing, and great for your baby to practice their teething on!

It’ll take the teething pain away because you can chill it to keep your baby cool and happy. A happy, cool teething baby is what every caregiver and mother would want.

Different reviews on this and other non-toxic teething toys from the same company share that they had bought it for baby showers and “it was a hit,” that they love it, and sure that their baby would too.

10. Oil and Carol Fruits and Veggies Teethers

Oil and Carol Fruits and Veggies Teethers

Oli & Carol is a Barcelona-based company founded by young sisters Olimpia and Carolina Roman.

It’s a company specialized in designing non-toxic toys made from 100% rubber from Hevea trees, which are safe and sustainable.

The absolute best thing about these fruit and veggies teething toys is they have some of the cutest fruit and veggie designs for your baby.

Some of the non-toxic teething toys that this company makes from this collection include designs such as:

  • Anna Banana
  • Wally the Watermelon
  • Ramona the Radish
  • Coco the Coconut
  • Merry the Cherry
  • Manolo the Mushroom

These are some of the cutest teething toys in the whole world!

Frequently Asked Questions About Teething Toys

Baby biting toy

Are Silicone Teething Toys Safe?

A lot of baby bottle nipples and organic infant pacifiers are actually made of silicone, so don’t worry about them harming your baby.

As long as the toy is made of FOOD-GRADE silicone, you don’t have to worry about any lingering toxic chemicals affecting your little one.

Are Plastic Teethers Safe?

Plastic is a BIG NO-NO when it comes to anything near your baby’s mouth. PVC/Vinyl is a common plastic that is widely used for different toys and other objects.

This plastic material can contain lead, heavy metals, and even phthalates that can prove to be harmful to children when ingested!

Are Fluid-Filled Teethers Safe?

We highly discourage using fluid-filled teethers. It’s possible for them to burst or break, possibly choking or harming your baby if the fluid is ingested.

If you already have a fluid-filled teether but don’t want to replace it yet, be sure to check the label and instructions on how to take care of it properly to avoid any accidents.

Are Teething Toys Bad for Babies?

All babies go through a teething stage before their toddler years.

Teething toys are specifically used to soothe a sore baby’s gums when their teeth start coming out, so don’t worry about them being harmful to your little one.

HOWEVER, not all teething toys are safe for babies (e.g., a teething toy that isn’t BPA-free)

As long as you pick toys SPECIFICALLY MADE for teething that are made of organic, natural, and safe materials, your baby will be fine!

When to Use Teether for Baby?

Babies usually start growing their teeth when they’re 3-7 months old.

Having a teething toy during this period will be a good idea to help soothe or alleviate any pain they’re experiencing from their gums and growing teeth.

Final Teething Thoughts

Even the cutest of teething toys should be made from safe, non-toxic materials. We only want what’s best for our babies, of course.

We hope you enjoyed this adorable list of the best teething toys for your little angel. All made with love for non-toxic teething!


August 3, 2022 – minor formatting edits

About the author

Angelica Graham

A few years ago, Angelica found out about all the plastic and toxic ingredients that got into most children’s products. And this worried her to no end. Because of this, she began to research what the best ingredients and materials were for children and made it her mission to share this information with other mothers.