The Good Nursery is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

6 Best Organic Pacifiers: Non-Toxic & Natural Rubber

6 Best Organic Pacifiers: Non-Toxic & Natural Rubber

Looking for the best baby paci for your bundle of joy? A pacifier is a great baby product that helps soothe and manage the natural sucking tendencies of babies.

Pacifiers can be a lifesaver for a lot of parents and they’re not as bad as some of you might think!

An organic pacifier is great since it lacks any synthetic substances and harmful chemicals. Although, non-toxic silicone pacifiers can also be just as great!

Whichever kind of pacifier you’re looking for, know that pacifiers are safe, effective, and handy tools that get the job done.

Take a look at these organic baby pacifiers and see which ones your baby would love!

Best Value
Our Pick
Best Silicone
Ecopiggy Ecopacifier
Philips Avent Pacifier
Our Pick
HEVEA Pacifier
Best Value
Ecopiggy Ecopacifier
Best Silicone
Philips Avent Pacifier
Table of Contents
Table of Contents

6 Best Organic and Non-Toxic Pacifiers

1. HEVEA Orthodontic Rubber Pacifier

OUR PICK

Our Pick

The HEVEA Star & Moon Rubber Pacifier is one of the best organic baby pacifiers out there.

Made of rubber from the tree Hevea Brasiliensis, it’s made from 100% natural rubber, making it soft, stretchy, and safe for your baby! It also has a one-piece design, so you don’t have to worry about any parts breaking off and become choking hazards.

Hevea pacifiers have ventilation holes shaped with moon and stars. These holes help prevent baby saliva from building up and cause any skin irritation.

Its orthodontic design also encourages proper oral development, which is a plus! This baby pacifier also has a butterfly shape that frees your baby’s nose and chin, making it more comfortable.

This pacifier is suited for babies who are 0-3 months old, but it also has a variant that’s suited for older babies who are 3 – 36 months old!

Pros

  • Free from BPA, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals
  • One-piece design
  • Orthodontic shape
  • Soft and comfortable

Cons

  • Rubber pacifiers don’t last as long
  • Not suitable for babies with latex allergies

2. Ecopiggy Ecopacifier Natural Pacifier

BEST VALUE

Best Value Rubber Pacifier

Rubber pacifiers need to be replaced more often compared to other material types. If you already know what your baby likes and you want to get a great value for your purchase, then the Ecopiggy Ecopacifier is your best bet!

This baby pacifier is made from 100% natural rubber, making it BPA-free and have no chemical softeners.

What’s great about this organic pacifier is that it comes in a 3-pack. This makes it stand out compared to other pacifiers that usually just come in ones. It’ll be easier for you to replace your pacifier and not have to purchase them again one by one!

You get to pick between two sizes for the round nipple design, one for 0-6 and the other for 6 months and up. There’s also an orthodontic 3-pack option for babies that are 6 months and above!

Pros

  • Gives great value and convenience
  • No harmful substances
  • One-piece design

Cons

  • Not suitable for babies with latex allergies
  • Not a butterfly shape

3. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

BEST SILICONE PACIFIER

Best Silicone Pacifier

With thousands of positive reviews on Amazon, this popular baby pacifier is a go-to for hospitals nationwide!

Made out of non-toxic medical-grade silicone, this pacifier is dishwasher safe, BPA-free, latex-free, and safe for your baby. Despite its round shape, it actually has an orthopedic design that still encourages proper oral development!

What’s great about this baby pacifier is that you have the option of getting the 2-pack or 4-pack for affordable prices! Since these are made out of silicone, expect to replace these every 6 months, which is a lot longer compared to natural rubber pacifiers.

This product is suitable for a 0-3-month-old baby, but there’s also a 3 months+ option if that’s what you’re looking for.

This comes in cute pink and purple colors that are perfect for your little girl, but if you’re looking for a different color, they have blue and green options too!

Pros

  • Non-toxic material
  • Orthodontic design
  • Affordable
  • Easy to clean and long-lasting
  • One-piece construction

Cons

  • Not as soft as rubber
  • Has no ring handle

4. Chicco PhysioForma Pacifier

Chicco PhysioForma Pacifier

If you’re looking for 100% food-grade silicone pacifiers and want to get a good value out of them, then the Chicco PhysioForma is one of the best choices out there!

Made in Italy, its orthodontic nipple design actively supports your baby’s breathing and guides proper tongue placement. This encourages the proper development of your baby’s mouth and palate.

This pacifier also has ventilation holes and a cutout on the top of the shield for your baby’s nose. It gives air circulation, prevents saliva from pooling, and gives a great comfy fit for your baby’s mouth!

What’s also great about this pacifier is that you can pick between three sizes which are 0-6 months, 6-16 months, and even 16-24 months!

This pacifier comes in a 2-pack with three color choices, and it also comes with a sterilizing case which is a plus!

Pros

  • Non-toxic one-piece design
  • Ergonomic shield and orthodontic design
  • Wide age range
  • Comes with a sterilizing case

Cons

  • Smallest size could still be too big for a younger baby
  • A bit heavier compared to other pacifiers

5. The UMMY 100% Natural Rubber Pacifier

The UMMY 100_ Natural Rubber Pacifier

The UMMY 100% pacifier is also a great organic option that was made in Italy! Made out of natural liquid rubber, this product was molded into one piece and has organic properties. This makes it BPA-free, phthalate-free, paraben-free, and has no chemical softeners, artificial colorants, and nitrosamines.

This product also undergoes a stretch test and the shield is designed to help with proper muscle development!

What’s great about this product is that you have three nipple designs to choose from being round, orthodontic, and elongated.

You also have four size choices, giving you a lot of options for whatever is best for your baby’s mouth. It has 0-6 months, 3-6 months, 6-12 months, and even 0-3 months for newborns!

Pros

  • No harmful substances
  • One-piece design
  • Multiple sizes and nipple designs

Cons

  • Not suitable for babies with latex allergy
  • Not a butterfly shape

6. Natursutten Natural Rubber Pacifier

Natursutten Natural Rubber Pacifier

Natursutten pacifiers are also great 100% natural rubber pacifiers that are made in Italy. This organic option is free from any chemical softeners, artificial coloring, phthalates, parabens, and BPA.

This one-piece rubber construction has two nipple shapes to choose from being round and orthodontic. You can also pick between three sizes which are 0-6 months, 6-12 months, and even 12 months and up!

The shield on this pacifier is also designed to graze your baby’s nose the same way how it would feel if he was breastfeeding. There’s also another cutout shield option that frees your baby’s nose.

This brand also claims to remove the latex protein that causes any allergies. If your baby is allergic to latex rubber, then this one might be safe to use.

Pros

  • No harmful substances
  • Thoughtful pacifier shield design
  • One-piece construction
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • More expensive compared to other pacifiers

What Is the Safest Pacifier?

Pacifiers are objects that come in direct contact with your baby. It’s important to make sure that the pacifier your baby is sucking on is non-toxic and designed well!

There are a couple of factors you should consider when picking the best pacifier for your little one.

Organic Pacifier Value Ed 1

1. Material

There are two main material types for pacifiers that are safe and recommended for babies:

  • Natural rubber
  • Silicone

Make sure to avoid plastic as much as possible!

Natural Rubber

Natural rubber pacifiers are the only organic option when it comes to a baby pacifier.

The four natural rubber options in this list are all made from natural latex rubber from the tree Hevea Brasiliensis in Malaysia. These pacifiers naturally have no harmful substances or chemicals added.

These pacifiers are also 100% organic and non-toxic for your baby, plus they’re also biodegradable!

Although, if your baby is allergic to latex rubber, then you should avoid these pacifiers at all costs, so be careful!

When it comes to rubber, they also wear down faster compared to silicone and tend to lose their shape over time.

With no chemical softeners and preservatives, you can expect these pacifiers to last for about 6-8 weeks before you should replace them.

Rubber pacifiers cost a little bit more compared to silicone ones and they usually come in a 1-pack. Since these also wear out fast, expect to spend more money and have more waste compared to having silicone pacifiers.

If you’re interested, you can also check out our list of natural baby teething toys for some products that also use natural rubber materials.

Silicone

Silicone pacifiers are still great options even though they aren’t 100% organic like natural rubber.

Although, keep in mind that it should either be medical-grade or food-grade silicone. These are tested and reviewed to the highest manufacturing standards.

This makes them safe and trustworthy for all sorts of products, especially baby products!

These kinds of silicones are non-toxic and free from any harmful substances like BPA, PVC, and phthalates. For those with a baby with allergies, these are latex-free too!

These pacifiers are not as soft as rubber ones, but they’re still soft enough to satisfy your baby’s sucking needs. Since they’re synthetic, they also last a long time and don’t lose their shape compared to natural rubber.

It also doesn’t soak up any odor and give off any rubbery taste that natural rubber pacifiers usually have.

Organic Pacifiers Value Ed 3

2. Design

The design of the pacifier is also an important factor to consider when deciding what’s most suited for your baby. Yup, clothes aren’t the only thing that depends on design.

Size

The size of the pacifier is something you shouldn’t brush off! There are baby pacifiers for 0-3, 3-6, 0-6, 6-12, and even higher.

Usually, the size of the nipple is the main difference between these different age recommendations, but the softness and flexibility can also be different.

It’s important to pick the appropriate pacifier size based on the age range that’s given from these products.

If an older baby uses a pacifier that was meant for a baby who is 0-3 months old, this can be a choking hazard for the baby.

Pacifiers for younger babies who have no teeth tend to be softer and flexible compared to pacifiers for older babies. If an older baby with teeth uses a newborn pacifier, this baby could tear, break, and even choke on it.

Nipple Shape

The nipple shape is something you can easily overlook, but it’s actually a factor that can affect your baby’s proper teeth and gums development!

There are two main nipple shapes you would usually see from pacifiers in the market.

One would be the standard rounded nipple, and the other is the orthodontic nipple:

  • The rounded nipple is shaped close to a mother’s and these are usually accepted by babies easily.
  • Orthodontic nipples have a flatter shape, being flat on the bottom and rounded on the top. This shape encourages natural oral development, protects your baby’s palate, and can position the tongue forward. It could help open up airways that can support physiological breathing.

There are other shapes such as elongated and symmetrical, but these aren’t as common.

We suggest going for the orthodontic shape as much as possible, but it would also depend on what your baby is most comfortable with. Some might reject orthodontic pacifiers, while some might love them.

Other shapes aren’t necessarily bad and discourage proper oral development, but orthodontic shapes have been designed to work best.

Test out different shapes and see what your baby likes best!

Construction

There are three main parts of a pacifier which are the nipple, the shield (or guard), and the handle.

The nipple is what (we hope) your baby will suck on, and the shield is what prevents the pacifier from falling into your baby’s mouth and become a choking hazard.

These guards usually have small ventilation holes that provide air circulation and prevent saliva from pooling between the inside of the guard and your baby’s skin. This would prevent any rashes or irritation to occur!

If ever your baby sucks in the entire pacifier, which rarely happens, the ventilation holes will also prevent their breathing from being obstructed!

There are standard pacifiers that have a three or two-piece construction of the nipple, shield, and handle. However, we recommend going for pacifiers with a single-piece construction.

A single-piece construction would mean that all parts of the pacifier are connected and molded together as one. This would reduce the chances of choking risk because no part of it can be detached or be broken apart!

Are Pacifiers Good for Babies?

There have been a lot of different reports on whether or not pacifiers are good or bad for babies. For one, they shouldn’t be immediately given to newborns, especially if you’ve undergone a natural birth at home.

You might have heard that pacifiers can cause nipple confusion, interfere with breastfeeding, and be a bad habit for your baby in the long run.

There are small truths in these statements, but pacifiers aren’t as bad as some might make them out to be!

That’s why they’re usually part of every newborn baby prep checklist you’ll find.

Organic Pacifier Value Ed 2

Breastfeeding Relationship

Contrary to common concerns about pacifiers, they don’t cause nipple confusion or interfere with breastfeeding at all. In fact, using pacifiers could even lead to a better breastfeeding relationship!

A baby naturally has a sucking reflex that soothes them and calms them down. When they cry, they either need nutritive sucking and feed on breast milk, or they just need the comforting sucking sensation that they’re looking for. This is when you can go for non-nutritive sucking or comfort sucking by giving them a pacifier!

Breastfeeding every day for hours can be exhausting, and most moms know how worn out they could feel at the end of the day.

Since pacifiers provide the sucking sensation that a baby looks for to calm down, a lot of moms found pacifiers to be their saving grace!

Assuming that they’re not hungry, using a pacifier to calm them down will not only give you more time to rest, but you and your baby will both be happier with your breastfeeding relationship!

However, keep in mind that you shouldn’t use a pacifier to delay your baby’s feeding.

Letting them suck on a pacifier when they’re hungry won’t soothe them and you’ll just have a harder time calming them down.

Sleeping

The sucking sensation for babies helps calm them down and puts them in a happier state. You’ll see that this is true when nursing your baby to sleep usually works like a charm!

Although sometimes, once you’ll lay them down on their crib, they’ll start crying and start looking for that soothing sucking sensation again.

Giving them a pacifier will solve their soothe-to-suck habit, putting them in a calmer state and make them fall asleep soundly. Don’t forget that you should only give them a pacifier for comfort sucking.

If they’re actually hungry, you’ll have to pick them up and breastfeed them first to make them full. Once they’re full, you can give them a pacifier as soon as you lay them down on the crib and watch them sleep soundly!

Sudden Infant Death Syndrome

Some studies have found that babies who use pacifiers when they sleep could lower the risk of sudden infant death syndrome.

Not a lot of studies have been 100% percent sure of this, but if you ask us, spending on pacifiers is worth the purchase if it could help prevent SIDS by even a little.

Your baby will have better sleep, you’ll have a better breastfeeding relationship, and you’ll likely have fewer things to worry about!

What Type of Pacifier Is Best for Breastfed Babies?

The type of pacifier that’s best for a breastfed baby would really depend on what pacifier your baby likes best.

Since pacifiers actually DON’T cause nipple confusion or ruin the breastfeeding relationship, you don’t have to worry about these as contributing factors.

Instead, try and figure out what nipple shape your baby would like best.

This could take some trial-and-error, but that’s expected when figuring out what your baby likes. Just make sure that you follow the recommended age that’s indicated on the pacifier.

Pacifier nipples for younger babies tend to be softer and more flexible, so these could help babies latch on to them better compared to pacifiers for older babies.

Conclusion

Our pick for the best organic pacifier would have to be HEVEA Star & Moon Orthodontic Rubber Pacifier. It’s soft, stretchy, and has great features like its orthodontic design and butterfly shape. This pacifier will surely satisfy your baby’s needs!

For those looking for an organic option with great value, the Ecopiggy Ecopacifier Natural Pacifier is also a product we recommend. With a 3-pack option, these rubber pacifiers will easily be replaceable and you don’t have to worry about repeatedly spending money on single purchases!

A hospital go-to, the Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier is a product that’s hard not to recommend. If you’re looking for a tried-and-tested medical-grade silicone pacifier, then this is the pacifier for you.

For more newborn baby essentials, we suggest you read through our Diaper Bag Checklist article to make sure that you’re all set for your little one’s arrival.


Changelog:

October 8, 2021 – Reviewed and updated article formatting and content

July 22, 2021 – updated article links

About the author

angelica-graham

A few years ago, Angelica found out about all the plastic and toxic ingredients that got into most children’s products. And this worried her to no end. Because of this, she began to research what the best ingredients and materials were for children and made it her mission to share this information with other mothers.